This is one of the first questions we get asked, and the honest answer is: it depends on what you need the site to do, not on which option sounds more “serious.”

Ask these questions first, not “which is better”

Who needs to edit content, and how often? If a non-technical person needs to add pages or articles every week without a developer, you need a proper editor. That used to mean a heavy platform with a database and a stack of plugins. It doesn’t have to: a custom-built site with an editor made for it, like our own Somnia CMS, gives your team the same freedom without the weight.

Does the site need to feel genuinely fast and bespoke? A site built for you gives you full control over performance and exactly how it feels to use: nothing generic, nothing borrowed from a theme. That matters more the more your website is part of your sales pitch.

What’s the realistic content velocity? A five-page marketing site with an occasional case study doesn’t need the overhead of a full platform. A handful of well-organised content files, edited through a simple editor, is often more reliable than a system that needs securing and updating forever.

Do you need a shop, memberships, or complex logic? Hosted store platforms have a genuine edge when you only need a simple catalogue, because building checkout logic from scratch rarely makes sense. We cover that in our guide to custom online stores.

Who’s maintaining it in two years? Anything made of plugins needs constant updates to stay secure, and each plugin is a place for something to break or slow the site down. A lean, built-ahead-of-time site has far less to patch: there is simply less running.

Our honest rule of thumb

  • A marketing, portfolio or product site where performance, accessibility and design matter → built for you, on a design system, with an editor your team can use.
  • A simple, standard catalogue you want live next week → a hosted store platform, with a good design on top.
  • Somewhere in between → a custom front end with a lightweight editor behind it gives you speed and easy editing without the maintenance burden of a plugin-heavy platform.

That in-between option is exactly why we built Somnia CMS. It edits the site you were given, can only change what the design allows, and publishes in minutes to a site that loads fast because nothing is assembled on the fly. We host it and look after it if you want us to.

Not sure which fits your situation? Tell us what you’re building and we’ll give you a straight answer.

← Back to all insights