Show reviews and kind words
What customers say is the most persuasive thing on a small business's site, and the easiest to get wrong. Show each thing as what it is: a review someone can check, or kind words the business kept.
Two different things
| Reviews | Kind words | |
|---|---|---|
| What they are | Left on a platform (Google, a trade feed) that anyone can look at | A thank-you note, a guest book, an email the business kept |
| Shown with | The overall score, how many there are, where they're from, and a link to check | Who wrote it and when. No stars, and no source it doesn't have |
| Component | Reviews | Testimonials |
Never mix them in one list, and never give kind words stars.
The rules
- Word for word. Not shortened, corrected or joined together. A long one is cut on screen with Read more, which hides nothing.
- With permission, and named as agreed. Follow the platform's terms for reviews, and the business's own terms for anything else. Headland's say first names and initials.
- Say whose customers they were. If the words are about the people rather than the business ("notes their guests left them, before Headland"), the heading says so, beside the quotes.
- The score is the real score. The number shown is the platform's, not the average of the ones chosen. A review without a rating shows no stars.
- Made-up examples never go live. While a site is being built, example reviews can stand in to try the layout. They show on the staging site only, under a notice saying what they are.
- One switch takes them all off. The business can turn reviews off across the site in Somnia CMS without deleting them, for the day a platform changes its terms or the reviews aren't ready.
- Show a few, and offer the rest. The first few, then "Show all 14 reviews". On paper the first ones print, with a line saying how many more the web page has.
Where they go
- Beside the decision they support: a yacht's reviews on that yacht's page, the business's on its home and About pages.
- Not in site search: each page should be found for its own words, not for a customer's.
Do and don't
Do
- Link to where a review can be checked
- Date everything
- Keep the less glowing ones if they are part of the score
Don't
- Write, edit or "tidy" a review
- Show stars for words that came with none
- Use a customer's full name or photo without asking
Accessibility
- A score is also given in words ("5 out of 5, from 6 reviews"); the stars are decoration.
- Each quote is marked as a quotation, with who said it after it.
- "Show all" is a real button that says whether the rest are showing.
Evidence
Where it's used
| Where | For |
|---|---|
| Headland Yachting | Each yacht’s own reviews on its page. Its Google reviews on the home page and About are switched off for now. |
What we saw, and what changed
| When | What we saw | What changed |
|---|---|---|
| Headland’s reviews were to come off its pages for now, and be kept. | A Show on the site switch that keeps them in the file (1.44.0). | |
| Closing a long list with Show fewer left the reader far down the page. | Closing takes the reader back to the start of what closed (1.49.1). | |
| A review with no rating was drawn, and averaged, as five stars. | Stars are shown only for a rating someone gave (1.77.0). | |
| Show all brought the rest in above the button and left the keyboard on the button, past them. | The first of them takes the focus, as it already did when they were shown a few at a time (1.85.0). |
From building and using it on real sites, each entry taken from the changelog or the build's own notes. This is observation by the studio and its clients, not research sessions with users.
What we don't know yet
- How many people open the rest, or follow the link to the source, is not counted.